At the end of each season Plattsburgh State hockey fans vote for their favorite Cardinal Hockey player. This past season, fans voted senior forward Andrew Willock as the 2010 Fan Favorite.

• 09-10 Andrew Willock - Forward
  
• 08-09 Bryan Hince - Goaltender
  
• 07-08 CJ Tozzo - Forward
  
• 06-07 Shane Remenda - Forward
  
• 05-06 Ryan Busby - Forward
  
• 04-05 Paul Kelly - Forward
  
• 03-04 Ryan Busby - Forward
  
• 02-03 Jason Kilcan - Forward
  
• 01-02 Niklas Sundberg - Goaltender
  
• 00-01 Niklas Sundberg - Goaltender
  
• 99-00 Eric Seidel - Forward
  
• 98-99 Derrick Shaw - Forward
  
• 97-98 Tim Pelletier - Forward
  
• 96-97 Steve Moffat - Forward
  
• 95-96 Tim Pelletier - Forward
  
• 94-95 John Wells - Forward
  
• 93-94 Lenny Pereira - Forward
  
• 92-93 Mike Mondello - Goaltender
  
• 91-91 Larry Zinger - Forward